Commentary: Trump’s tariffs would be worse than Biden’s inflation

Anybody stinging from the sticker shock of inflation during Joe Biden’s presidency should be alarmed at what might be coming if Donald Trump becomes the next president: tariffs on imports that could be even more painful.

Trump wants to impose new tariffs of 20% on most imports, with a 60% tariff on products from China. That’s on top of more modest tariffs Trump already imposed during his presidency. Americans buy $3.8 billion worth of imports every year, more than any other nation. That's nearly as much as Americans spend on healthcare, and you’ll never hear a presidential candidate promising to raise healthcare costs by adding new taxes.

Trump says tariffs are not taxes. He’s wrong, and it’s not a matter of interpretation. Tariffs are a customs duty paid by American importers. The Treasury Department reports revenue from customs duties the same as it reports revenue from income and corporate taxes. The government’s tariff revenue doubled, from $38 billion in 2017 to $77 billion in 2019, after Trump’s first set of tariffs went into effect.

Right before COVID hit in 2020, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated the Trump tariffs would raise prices by 0.5%, reduce GDP by 0.5%, and cost the average household $1,277 via higher prices and slower economic growth. The COVID pandemic, combined with unprecedented amounts of government stimulus, distorted the economy and made it hard to validate such forecasts.

Republican presidential nominee and former President Donald Trump speaks at a rally in Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S. Sept. 13, 2024. (REUTERS/Piroschka Van de Wouw/File Photo) · (REUTERS / Reuters)

But Trump’s tariffs most likely contributed to the inflation surge under Biden, with the inflation rate peaking at 9% in 2022. Biden repealed the Trump tariffs on allied nations, but he kept the China tariffs in place. That adds a tax of 7.5% to 25% on about $280 billion worth of imports each year, according to the American Action Forum. Federal revenue from tariffs is still double the pre-COVID level.

Trump’s new round of tariffs would cost the typical household an additional $2,600 per year in higher costs and slower growth, according to the Peterson Institute for International Economics. That would probably be a bigger hit to American wallets than inflation has exacted since Biden took office.

The average household spent $66,928 in 2021, Biden’s first year in office. Since January 2021, overall price levels have risen 19.7%, while incomes have risen by 17.6%. So inflation has exceeded incomes by 2.1 percentage points during that time. That erosion of purchasing power is the “cost” of inflation.

If average expenditures rose by 19.7% since 2021, while incomes only rose 17.6%, the cost of inflation was a loss in purchasing power equivalent to $1,405. That covers a three-year period, so divide by three and you get $468 per year in added costs. That might seem suspiciously low to large families with a lot of mouths to feed and rising rent. But it also covers smaller households able to substitute away from costlier goods, plus millions of homeowners whose housing costs fell after they refinanced their mortgages at record low interest rates in 2020 and 2021.